Skip to content
Fryer & Feast

Turkey Fryers

Masterbuilt Butterball XL Electric Turkey Fryer Review

The indoor electric fryer most first-time hosts should buy — and three specific situations where it is the wrong choice.

By Mike M. · Published · Last updated

An electric fryer standing on a kitchen countertop

How this page is funded: Fryer & Feast is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program, and in brand partner programs run through the Impact network — currently Pit Boss, which sells direct. If you buy through a link here we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never changes which products we recommend — see how we pick and our full affiliate disclosure. Every buy link goes straight to the retailer, so the price you see is the live one on the day you buy.

The verdict: buy it if your bird is 20 pounds or under and you want the smallest possible chance of something going badly wrong. Do not buy it if you are cooking for a large crowd on one bird, if your kitchen counter is already full, or if what you actually want is your oven back — in that last case a roaster oven is cheaper and better suited.

Quick picks

#ProductBest forScorePrice
1
No image
Masterbuilt Butterball XL Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer20 lb capacity, 2.75 gallons, thermostatic, lives indoors.
The one being reviewed9.3/10
2
Masterbuilt MB20012420 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer, Boiler & Steamer
Masterbuilt MB20012420 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer, Boiler & SteamerSame platform with a boiler and steamer built around it.
The closest alternative9.4/10

Scores are our own editorial rubric, explained on how we pick. Four criteria per category on a published 8.4-9.8 scale, so the leading pick is clear at a glance. A product scores the same here as it does on every other page of this site.

What it is, and who it is for

The Butterball XL is a sealed stainless countertop fryer with an integrated heating element, a thermostat, a drain valve and a basket. You fill it with about 2.75 gallons of oil, set it to 350F, and it brings itself up and holds there while you get on with the sides.

It exists for one reason: to let people fry a turkey without standing over an open propane flame with five gallons of hot oil on a stand. If you have read our safety guide and quietly decided frying might not be for you, this is the machine that changes that calculation.

What it does well

The oil volume is the headline

Roughly 2.75 gallons against four to five for a 30-quart propane pot. That is less oil to buy, less to heat, less to cool and far less to dispose of. It also means a smaller spill if anything goes wrong, which matters more than the cost saving.

Temperature recovery

A smaller volume of oil under thermostatic control recovers faster after the bird goes in. Faster recovery is the whole game in frying: oil that drops and stays low soaks into the skin instead of sealing it.

It gets used again

The boil and steam functions are not marketing. A pot that will hold a rolling boil for seafood or corn earns its storage space in a way a 30-quart outdoor rig never does.

The trade-offs, stated plainly

Twenty pounds is a hard ceiling. Not a conservative rating — a physical one. Measure your bird. If you are feeding a crowd, two 12-pound turkeys cooked in sequence beat one 22-pound bird you cannot fit, and they cook more evenly besides.

It is genuinely large. Full of oil it is heavy and you will not want to move it. Decide where it is going to stand before the day, with a clear path and nothing above it.

The electrical load is real. At around 1,650 watts it takes most of a 15-amp circuit. Share that circuit with a microwave and you will trip the breaker mid-cook. Give it its own outlet and skip the extension cord.

Masterbuilt’s fryer line has had patchy availability. It is worth checking stock early rather than assuming it will be there in the third week of November.

What this review is built on

This review is built on the manufacturer’s published capacity and oil volume, owner feedback read at scale for repeated problems rather than isolated complaints, and how the design measures against the published safety guidance from the National Turkey Federation and State Farm. The full method is set out on how we pick.

Honest alternatives

Want it to do more? The Masterbuilt MB20012420 is the same idea with boiling and steaming built in.

Want no oil at all? The Char-Broil Big Easy cooks with infrared heat and no oil whatsoever — see our oil-less guide.

Bird over 20 pounds? You need an outdoor propane pot, or the better answer for most people: an electric roaster oven, which takes a 26-pound bird with no oil at all.

The bigger sibling is covered separately. If your bird is over 20 pounds, or you want a thermostat that holds its own temperature rather than a manual dial, read the Butterball XXL Digital review before you buy this one.

Want to see the whole range first? Which Butterball turkey fryer to buy ranks every Butterball-badged model on sale, and the best electric turkey fryer page widens that out to the whole indoor category.

The products, in detail

#1 · The one being reviewed

Masterbuilt Butterball XL Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

9.3/10

The safest realistic first fryer: it lives indoors on a countertop, holds a 20-pound bird, and takes about a third of the oil a propane rig needs.

Type
Indoor electric
Max bird
Up to 20 lb
Oil
About 2.75 gallons
Also does
Boil and steam

Why we picked it

  • No flame, no tank, no wind — most fryer risks removed by design
  • About 2.75 gallons of oil, not four to five
  • Thermostat holds 350F while you do something else
  • Boil and steam modes make it useful outside November

Good to know

Hard 20 lb ceiling on the bird

Safety

9.8

Ease of use

9.6

Capacity

8.4

Value

8.9

#2 · The closest alternative

Masterbuilt MB20012420 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer, Boiler & Steamer

9.4/10

The three-in-one version of the same idea — fry, boil or steam — which is the difference between an appliance you use once a year and one you use monthly.

Type
Indoor electric
Max bird
Up to 20 lb
Modes
Fry, boil, steam
Pot
10.6 qt, basket included

Why we picked it

  • Three modes instead of one
  • Same indoor-electric safety profile
  • Basket included

Good to know

Same 20 lb ceiling

Safety

9.8

Ease of use

9.2

Versatility

9.7

Value

8.7

Frequently asked questions

Up to 20 pounds. That is the manufacturer ceiling and it is a physical constraint, not a cautious estimate. Weigh the bird before you buy the fryer.

Our recommendation

If you only take one thing from this page: buy the Butterball XL. If that is not the right fit for your setup, the Masterbuilt 3-in-1 XL is the one to get instead.

The one being reviewed

9.3/10

Masterbuilt Butterball XL Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

20 lb capacity, 2.75 gallons, thermostatic, lives indoors.

Runner-up — The closest alternative

9.4/10

Masterbuilt MB20012420 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer, Boiler & Steamer

Same platform with a boiler and steamer built around it.

Brands: want your product tested? For Brands.

Sources

Related reading