Skip to content
Fryer & Feast

Turkey Fryers

The Best Oil for Frying a Turkey

You need an oil with a smoke point comfortably above 350F, a neutral flavor, and a price that survives being bought five gallons at a time.

By Mike M. · Published · Last updated

Cooking oil being poured from a bottle

How this page is funded: Fryer & Feast is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program, and in brand partner programs run through the Impact network — currently Pit Boss, which sells direct. If you buy through a link here we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never changes which products we recommend — see how we pick and our full affiliate disclosure. Every buy link goes straight to the retailer, so the price you see is the live one on the day you buy.

The short answer: use refined peanut oil. Its smoke point sits around 450F, comfortably above the 350F you will be cooking at, and its flavor is neutral enough to stay out of the way. If anyone at your table has a nut allergy, high-oleic sunflower or canola oil does the same job at a similar temperature.

The National Turkey Federation lists peanut, canola, corn, rice and sunflower oils as suitable — the common thread is a high smoke point, not the plant it came from.

Quick picks

#ProductBest forScorePrice
1
ANF Brands Pure Peanut Oil, 4.5 Gallon Jug
ANF Brands Pure Peanut Oil, 4.5 Gallon JugAbout 450F smoke point, neutral, and sold by the gallon.
Best overall frying oil9.3/10
2
Baja Precious High Oleic Sunflower Oil, 1 Gallon
Baja Precious High Oleic Sunflower Oil, 1 GallonSame working temperature, no peanut in the conversation.
Best nut-free option9.3/10
3
CDN Deep Fry Thermometer, 12 Inch Long Stem
CDN Deep Fry Thermometer, 12 Inch Long StemSmoke point only protects you if you know the temperature.
Buy with the oil9.3/10

Scores are our own editorial rubric, explained on how we pick. Four criteria per category on a published 8.4-9.8 scale, so the leading pick is clear at a glance. A product scores the same here as it does on every other page of this site.

Smoke point is the whole decision

Every frying oil has a temperature at which it stops behaving like oil and starts breaking down — the smoke point. Past it the oil tastes acrid, releases irritating fumes, and moves measurably closer to its flash point. State Farm’s guidance is unambiguous: if you see the oil smoking, turn the fryer off.

You cook at 350F. You want at least 50F of headroom, and 100F is better, because the moment you lower a cold bird in the temperature swings and the burner works hard to recover.

OilApproximate smoke pointSuitable for frying a turkey?
Refined peanutAbout 450FYes — the default
High-oleic sunflowerAbout 440-450FYes — best nut-free choice
Refined canolaAbout 400-450FYes — cheapest workable option
CornAbout 450FYes
Extra-virgin oliveAbout 350-375FNo — too close to cooking temperature
Unrefined or cold-pressed oilsLow, variesNo

How much oil to buy

Buy three gallons for a 30-quart pot and a bird up to about 14 pounds; four to five for a bigger bird or a 44-quart pot; and about three gallons for an indoor electric, which typically needs 2.75.

Those are shopping-list numbers, not pouring numbers. The actual volume depends on the bird displacing oil in your specific pot, which is why you measure with water first — the method is in our oil volume guide. Buy the extra gallon anyway. Running short mid-pour is far worse than having oil left over.

The peanut allergy question, answered properly

Highly refined peanut oil has the peanut protein removed during processing, and it is that protein — not the oil itself — that triggers an allergic reaction. Refined peanut oil is therefore considered safe for most people with peanut allergies, and it is the standard frying oil in a great many commercial kitchens for precisely this reason.

That is not a license to skip the conversation. Cold-pressed, expeller-pressed and gourmet peanut oils retain protein and are not safe. If someone at your table has a severe allergy, use high-oleic sunflower or canola and tell them what you used. Nobody has ever been upset by being asked.

Reusing and disposing of the oil

Let the oil cool completely — the National Turkey Federation is explicit about this, and a pot of 300F oil is exactly as dangerous at 9pm as it was at 2pm. Then strain it through a fine sieve or cheesecloth into the original jugs and store it cold and dark.

Good oil will take two or three more fries. Throw it out when it darkens noticeably, smells sour or fishy, foams at the surface, or begins smoking at a lower temperature than it used to. Never pour it down a drain. Many municipal recycling sites and restaurants take used cooking oil — ring first.

Two things to settle before the day rather than after it: whether this jug has another fry in it, and where the oil goes when it does not. We cover both in can you reuse turkey fryer oil and how to dispose of turkey fryer oil.

Every pick, in detail

#1 · Best overall frying oil

ANF Brands Pure Peanut Oil, 4.5 Gallon Jug

9.3/10

Peanut oil is the default for a reason: a high smoke point and a flavour that does not fight the bird. One 4.5-gallon jug covers a 30-quart pot with margin.

Volume
4.5 gallon jug
Type
Pure peanut oil
Also
Kosher certified
Reuse
Strain and refrigerate, 2-3 fries

Why we picked it

  • Smoke point around 450F, a full 100F above your cooking temperature
  • Neutral flavor that lets the brine come through
  • Widely stocked in three-gallon jugs in November
  • Refined peanut oil is safe for most people with peanut allergies

Good to know

The most expensive mainstream option at volume

Smoke point

9.8

Flavor

9.3

Availability

9.0

Value

8.4

#2 · Best nut-free option

Baja Precious High Oleic Sunflower Oil, 1 Gallon

9.3/10

The peanut-allergy answer. High-oleic sunflower is expeller pressed, neutral in flavour and stable at frying heat, so nobody has to ask what the oil is.

Volume
1 gallon
Type
100% high-oleic sunflower
Processing
Expeller pressed, non-GMO
Why
No peanut in the kitchen

Why we picked it

  • Smoke point around 440-450F, effectively the same as peanut
  • Usually cheaper per gallon
  • Removes an allergy question entirely
  • Holds up to reuse as well as peanut does

Good to know

Less consistently stocked in bulk jugs

Smoke point

9.6

Flavor

9.2

Availability

8.4

Value

9.3

#3 · Buy with the oil

CDN Deep Fry Thermometer, 12 Inch Long Stem

9.3/10

A dial on a 12-inch stem that reads oil temperature continuously. The gauge built into a cheap kit is often the thing that is wrong.

Range
100F to 500F
Stem
12 in stainless
Dial
1.75 in, glass lens
Reads
Oil, not meat

Why we picked it

  • Reads oil continuously as it climbs to 350F
  • Long stem clears a deep pot
  • Costs a fraction of the oil it protects

Good to know

Dial thermometers drift — check it in boiling water first

Accuracy

9.0

Build

8.9

Ease of use

9.3

Value

9.6

Frequently asked questions

Usually yes — most supermarket “vegetable oil” is refined soybean or canola with a smoke point in the 400-450F range. Check the label for a stated smoke point or the word refined, and avoid anything cold-pressed or unrefined.

Our recommendation

If you only take one thing from this page: buy the ANF peanut oil, 4.5 gal. If that is not the right fit for your setup, the Baja high-oleic oil is the one to get instead.

Best frying oil

9.3/10

ANF Brands Pure Peanut Oil, 4.5 Gallon Jug

About 450F smoke point, neutral, and sold by the gallon.

Runner-up — Best nut-free option

9.3/10

Baja Precious High Oleic Sunflower Oil, 1 Gallon

Same working temperature, no peanut in the conversation.

Brands: want your product tested? For Brands.

Sources

Related reading