Skip to content
Fryer & Feast

Turkey Fryers

Masterbuilt vs Butterball Turkey Fryer

This comparison surprises people: Masterbuilt manufactures the Butterball fryers. The real decision is whether you want one job done or three.

By Mike M. · Published · Last updated

A cooking pot set up on a burner

How this page is funded: Fryer & Feast is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program, and in brand partner programs run through the Impact network — currently Pit Boss, which sells direct. If you buy through a link here we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never changes which products we recommend — see how we pick and our full affiliate disclosure. Every buy link goes straight to the retailer, so the price you see is the live one on the day you buy.

Get the Butterball XL if you want the simplest possible path to a fried turkey and you are unlikely to use it for anything else.

Get the Masterbuilt MB20012420 if you want an appliance that boils shrimp and steams corn in July as well as frying a turkey in November, and you do not mind washing a few more parts.

Quick picks

#ProductBest forScorePrice
1
No image
Masterbuilt Butterball XL Indoor Electric Turkey FryerThe Butterball-branded fryer: simplest to run, fewest parts.
Get this if you want one job done well9.3/10
2
Masterbuilt MB20012420 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer, Boiler & Steamer
Masterbuilt MB20012420 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer, Boiler & SteamerFry, boil and steam, so it comes out more than once a year.
Get this if it needs to earn its shelf9.4/10

Scores are our own editorial rubric, explained on how we pick. Four criteria per category on a published 8.4-9.8 scale, so the leading pick is clear at a glance. A product scores the same here as it does on every other page of this site.

First, the thing nobody tells you

Masterbuilt makes the Butterball electric turkey fryers under license. They are not rival products from rival companies — they are two lines from the same manufacturer, sharing the same fundamental design: a sealed stainless pot, a thermostatic element, a drain valve, a basket, a 20-pound ceiling and around 2.75 gallons of oil.

So every comparison page presenting this as a brand battle is answering a question that does not exist. The real difference is feature set, and that difference is genuinely worth thinking about.

Side by side

 Butterball XLMasterbuilt MB20012420
Made byMasterbuiltMasterbuilt
PlacementIndoor countertopIndoor countertop
Max bird20 lb20 lb
OilAbout 2.75 galAbout 2.75 gal
ModesFry, boilFry, boil, steam
Parts to cleanFewerMore
Off-season useOccasionalRegular
AvailabilityBetterPatchier

What is identical, and therefore not a tiebreaker

Both are indoor electric, so both remove the flame, the tank, the wind and the uneven ground. Both hold 350F on a thermostat rather than your attention. Both want their own electrical circuit at around 1,650 watts. Both stop dead at 20 pounds.

And critically, both require a completely thawed, completely dry bird. Moving the fryer indoors does not change the physics — water at the bottom of hot oil still flashes to steam and pushes oil out. That rule is the same on every fryer ever made.

Which one should you actually buy

For a genuine first-timer whose main anxiety is doing this wrong, take the Butterball XL. Fewer parts means fewer decisions on a day you already have too many, and it is the easier of the two to find in stock in November.

If you cook seafood boils, steam vegetables in quantity, or simply resent appliances that come out once a year, the MB20012420 is the better long-term buy. The boil function is genuinely good and it is the thing that stops this becoming another dusty box in the garage.

If neither appeals because 20 pounds is not enough, read our sizing guide before you jump to a propane pot — the answer is usually two smaller birds, not a bigger fryer.

Still weighing the badge rather than the model? Which Butterball turkey fryer to buy ranks all four Butterball-badged units, including the two Professional Series pots that appear on no other page here.

The products, in detail

#1 · Get this if you want one job done well

Masterbuilt Butterball XL Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

9.3/10

The safest realistic first fryer: it lives indoors on a countertop, holds a 20-pound bird, and takes about a third of the oil a propane rig needs.

Type
Indoor electric
Max bird
Up to 20 lb
Oil
About 2.75 gallons
Also does
Boil and steam

Why we picked it

  • Fewest components to assemble, clean and dry
  • The most widely stocked of the two
  • Butterball branding means clear capacity documentation

Good to know

Fries and boils, but the boil mode is secondary

Simplicity

9.8

Safety

9.8

Versatility

8.6

Value

8.9

#2 · Get this if it needs to earn its shelf

Masterbuilt MB20012420 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer, Boiler & Steamer

9.4/10

The three-in-one version of the same idea — fry, boil or steam — which is the difference between an appliance you use once a year and one you use monthly.

Type
Indoor electric
Max bird
Up to 20 lb
Modes
Fry, boil, steam
Pot
10.6 qt, basket included

Why we picked it

  • Genuine three-in-one, not a marketing claim
  • Boil mode handles seafood and corn properly
  • Basket included rather than sold on

Good to know

More parts, more washing

Simplicity

8.9

Safety

9.8

Versatility

9.7

Value

8.7

Frequently asked questions

The fryers are. Masterbuilt manufactures the Butterball-branded electric turkey fryers under license, so they share a design, capacity and oil volume. Butterball itself is a turkey brand, not an appliance manufacturer.

Our recommendation

If you only take one thing from this page: buy the Butterball XL. If that is not the right fit for your setup, the Masterbuilt 3-in-1 XL is the one to get instead.

Get this if you want one job done well

9.3/10

Masterbuilt Butterball XL Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

The Butterball-branded fryer: simplest to run, fewest parts.

Runner-up — Get this if it needs to earn its shelf

9.4/10

Masterbuilt MB20012420 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer, Boiler & Steamer

Fry, boil and steam, so it comes out more than once a year.

Brands: want your product tested? For Brands.

Sources

Related reading