Skip to content
Fryer & Feast

Turkey Fryers

Propane vs Electric Turkey Fryer

This is the fork in the road, and for a first-time host it is not close. Here is the case for each, and the honest recommendation.

By Mike M. · Published · Last updated

A propane tank beside outdoor cooking equipment

How this page is funded: Fryer & Feast is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program, and in brand partner programs run through the Impact network — currently Pit Boss, which sells direct. If you buy through a link here we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never changes which products we recommend — see how we pick and our full affiliate disclosure. Every buy link goes straight to the retailer, so the price you see is the live one on the day you buy.

Get an electric fryer if your bird is 20 pounds or under, this is your first time, or you would rather not spend the afternoon managing an open flame under five gallons of hot oil.

Get a propane fryer if you need to cook a bird over 20 pounds, you want the fastest possible cook, or you already fry outdoors and know the drill.

Quick picks

#ProductBest forScorePrice
1
No image
Masterbuilt Butterball XL Indoor Electric Turkey FryerIndoors, thermostatic, a third of the oil, no flame.
Get electric if this is your first time9.3/10
2
King Kooker 1266 Portable Propane Outdoor Turkey Fryer, 29 Quart
King Kooker 1266 Portable Propane Outdoor Turkey Fryer, 29 QuartA bird up to about 21 lb, and a complete kit in one box.
Get propane if you need the capacity9.0/10

Scores are our own editorial rubric, explained on how we pick. Four criteria per category on a published 8.4-9.8 scale, so the leading pick is clear at a glance. A product scores the same here as it does on every other page of this site.

The comparison, attribute by attribute

 Electric (indoor)Propane (outdoor)
Where it runsKitchen countertopOutdoors, level ground, clear of structures
Max birdAbout 20 lb21-25 lb depending on pot
Oil neededAbout 2.75 gal4-5 gal
Temperature controlThermostatYour hand on the regulator
Time to 350FTypically 30-45 minTypically 45-60 min
WeatherIrrelevantWind and rain both matter
Open flameNoneYes
Typical costHigher up frontLower up front, more oil
StorageLarge appliancePot, stand, burner, hose
Worst realistic failureA spill on the kitchen floorA structure fire

The safety gap is the whole argument

Both configurations heat oil to 350F, so both can burn you. The difference is how much can go wrong around that.

On propane you are managing an open flame, a pressurized tank, a stand that has to stay level under a growing load, wind that affects the burner, and — per State Farm’s guidance — a required two feet of separation between burner and tank. The National Turkey Federation adds: never on a wooden deck, never in a garage, never indoors. Each rule exists because somebody broke it.

On an indoor electric, almost none of that applies. What remains is the one rule that never goes away: the bird must be completely thawed and dry. That single failure — ice meeting hot oil — is behind most fryer incidents on any fuel.

For context on where the fire service lands, the NFPA discourages oil turkey fryers generally and points people toward oil-less units or a bought fried turkey.

Where propane genuinely wins

Capacity, and it is not close. Twenty pounds is a wall on every indoor electric. A 30-quart propane pot handles birds up to around 18 pounds comfortably and a 44-quart pot reaches 25.

Propane also has raw power. A strong burner recovers oil temperature faster after the bird goes in, which produces a crisper skin. And a full kit costs less than a comparable indoor electric.

Before you buy on capacity alone, though, read our guide to feeding twenty. Two 13-pound birds almost always beat one 26-pound bird — they cook faster, more evenly, and they fit equipment you can actually lift.

What each one really costs

The sticker price misleads. A propane kit is cheaper up front and then wants four to five gallons of oil, a propane refill, and a disposal plan. An indoor electric costs more up front and needs about 2.75 gallons and no fuel. Over two or three seasons the gap narrows considerably.

The costs nobody counts are storage and reuse. A 30-quart pot and stand is a large thing to keep for eleven months. An indoor electric that also boils and steams gets used repeatedly. That is a real difference in value, even if it never appears on a price tag.

Our recommendation

For a first-time host: electric. Buy a bird under 20 pounds to suit it, or cook two. The reduction in things that can go wrong is worth more on the day than the extra capacity.

For someone who has fried before and wants a bigger bird faster: propane, with elbow-length gloves and a grease-rated extinguisher bought at the same time. Both are in our accessories guide.

And if the real goal is freeing up your oven rather than frying at all, an electric roaster oven does that with no oil and takes a 26-pound bird.

If propane is the answer, the complete outdoor kits — burner, stand, pot, rack and hook — are ranked in best propane turkey fryers, where wind protection matters more than burner output.

If electric is the answer, the best electric turkey fryer picks rank the indoor units against each other, and which Butterball turkey fryer to buy covers the badge most of them carry.

The products, in detail

#1 · Get electric if this is your first time

Masterbuilt Butterball XL Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

9.3/10

The safest realistic first fryer: it lives indoors on a countertop, holds a 20-pound bird, and takes about a third of the oil a propane rig needs.

Type
Indoor electric
Max bird
Up to 20 lb
Oil
About 2.75 gallons
Also does
Boil and steam

Why we picked it

  • No open flame and no propane tank to manage
  • 2.75 gallons instead of four to five
  • Weather stops being part of the plan
  • Holds 350F without supervision

Good to know

20 lb ceiling

Safety

9.8

Ease of use

9.6

Capacity

8.4

Value

8.9

#2 · Get propane if you need the capacity

King Kooker 1266 Portable Propane Outdoor Turkey Fryer, 29 Quart

9.0/10

The value propane kit: a 38,000 BTU cast burner, a 29-quart aluminum pot, the listed hose and regulator, and the turkey rack and lifting hook already in the box.

Type
Outdoor propane kit
Pot
Aluminum, 29 qt
Burner
38,000 BTU cast
Included
Cooker, hose and regulator, rack and hook

Why we picked it

  • Handles birds no indoor electric will take
  • Faster to temperature with a strong burner
  • Cheapest route into real frying

Good to know

Open flame, outdoors, with every rule that implies

Safety

8.4

Ease of use

8.4

Capacity

9.5

Value

9.6

Frequently asked questions

Materially, yes. It removes the open flame, the propane tank, the outdoor stand and the weather. It does not remove the need for a completely thawed bird and correctly measured oil, which is the failure behind most fryer incidents regardless of fuel.

Our recommendation

If you only take one thing from this page: buy the Butterball XL. If that is not the right fit for your setup, the King Kooker 1266 kit is the one to get instead.

Get electric if this is your first time

9.3/10

Masterbuilt Butterball XL Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

Indoors, thermostatic, a third of the oil, no flame.

Runner-up — Get propane if you need the capacity

9.0/10

King Kooker 1266 Portable Propane Outdoor Turkey Fryer, 29 Quart

A bird up to about 21 lb, and a complete kit in one box.

Brands: want your product tested? For Brands.

Sources

Related reading