Skip to content
Fryer & Feast

Turkey Fryers

Turkey Fryer Accessories Worth Buying

Most fryer kits ship with a basket and a thermometer that is wrong. These are the six things that change how the day goes.

By Mike M. · Published · Last updated

Kitchen tongs and utensils laid out on a surface

How this page is funded: Fryer & Feast is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program, and in brand partner programs run through the Impact network — currently Pit Boss, which sells direct. If you buy through a link here we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never changes which products we recommend — see how we pick and our full affiliate disclosure. Every buy link goes straight to the retailer, so the price you see is the live one on the day you buy.

Buy these two first: elbow-length heat gloves and a grease-rated fire extinguisher. Neither comes in a fryer kit, both cost less than the oil, and they are the only two items on this page that change what happens when something goes wrong rather than how well the turkey turns out.

Quick picks

#ProductBest forScorePrice
1
GEEKHOM 18 in Heat-Resistant Waterproof Cooking Gloves
GEEKHOM 18 in Heat-Resistant Waterproof Cooking GlovesOven mitts stop at the wrist. Hot oil does not.
Buy this first9.5/10
2
First Alert Standard Kitchen Fire Extinguisher
First Alert Standard Kitchen Fire ExtinguisherA grease fire cannot be put out with water.
The one nobody sells you9.5/10
3
ThermoWorks Thermapen ONE Instant-Read Thermometer
ThermoWorks Thermapen ONE Instant-Read ThermometerThe fryer's dial reads oil. This reads dinner.
Best thermometer for the bird9.6/10
4
CDN Deep Fry Thermometer, 12 Inch Long Stem
CDN Deep Fry Thermometer, 12 Inch Long StemA long-stem dial that clips to the rim and stays put.
Best oil thermometer9.3/10
5
King Kooker Turkey Rack and Lifting Hook Kit
King Kooker Turkey Rack and Lifting Hook KitMakes the most dangerous 20 seconds a controlled movement.
Best lifting gear9.3/10
6
ANF Brands Pure Peanut Oil, 4.5 Gallon Jug
ANF Brands Pure Peanut Oil, 4.5 Gallon JugHigh smoke point, neutral, and sold in the right quantity.
Best frying oil9.3/10

Scores are our own editorial rubric, explained on how we pick. Four criteria per category on a published 8.4-9.8 scale, so the leading pick is clear at a glance. A product scores the same here as it does on every other page of this site.

What fryer kits leave out on purpose

A complete propane kit ships with a pot, a basket, a burner, a stand, a hose and a thermometer. That looks like everything until you are standing over five gallons of 350F oil holding a twelve-pound wet bird in two oven mitts.

The gaps are consistent across brands: no protective gloves, no extinguisher, and a dial thermometer accurate enough to be reassuring but not accurate enough to be relied on. None of those omissions is malicious — they are cost decisions. They are also the three things that decide how the afternoon goes.

Why you need two thermometers, not one

This trips up nearly everyone. The thermometer clipped to your pot measures oil. It tells you when to lower the bird in and whether the temperature has crashed. It tells you nothing at all about whether the turkey is safe to eat.

For that you need an instant-read probe in the thickest part of the breast and the inner thigh, reading 165F. That is the number the published frying guidance gives for doneness, and it is not negotiable. Two thermometers, two jobs — the full explanation is in our thermometer placement guide.

What you can safely skip

Marinade injectors are fun and almost entirely cosmetic if you have brined properly. Fryer covers matter only if the rig lives outside year-round. Turkey stands and racks that promise “even frying” do nothing a basket does not.

Skip the branded seasoning sold alongside the kit and buy a proper brine kit instead — it changes the meat, not just the surface.

The accessory nobody lists: somewhere to put the oil

Five gallons of used oil has to go somewhere, and it cannot go down a drain. Work this out before you start, not at ten at night with a full pot cooling on your patio.

The National Turkey Federation is clear that the oil must cool completely before you handle it. Once cool, strain it through a fine sieve into the original jugs. Stored cold and dark it will take another two or three fries. When you are finished with it, many municipal recycling centers and restaurants accept used cooking oil — call ahead rather than assuming.

The one accessory category worth ranking on its own is the thing that gets the bird out of the pot — see the best turkey lifters and hooks, which puts the fryer hook, the roaster rack and the basket against each other.

Two decisions that sit alongside the accessory list. Whether the pot itself should be stainless or aluminum is settled in stainless vs aluminum fryer pots, and what each material tolerates at the end of the night is in how to clean a turkey fryer.

Every pick, in detail

#1 · Buy this first

GEEKHOM 18 in Heat-Resistant Waterproof Cooking Gloves

9.5/10

Long-sleeve and waterproof, which is the pair that matters: hot oil splashes up your forearm, and a short glove just moves the burn.

Length
18 in sleeve
Rated
To 932F
Coating
Waterproof neoprene, silicone grip
Lining
Cotton

Why we picked it

  • Covers the forearm, which is the part that gets hit
  • Textured grip works when the outside is wet
  • Cheap enough that there is no argument for skipping it

Good to know

Bulky, so practice the lift before the day

Safety value

9.8

Build

9.0

Comfort

8.6

Value

9.8

#2 · The one nobody sells you

First Alert Standard Kitchen Fire Extinguisher

9.5/10

Grease fires are not water fires. A BC-rated extinguisher within arm's reach is the single item that separates an incident from a claim.

State Farm is blunt about this: never use water or a garden hose on a turkey fryer fire — it is a grease fire and water spreads it. An ABC or grease-rated extinguisher within reach is the difference between an incident and a claim.

Rating
UL 5-B:C
Agent
Sodium bicarbonate
Never use
Water on an oil fire
Check
Push-button pressure check before the day

Why we picked it

  • Class K or BC is rated for cooking-oil fires
  • Lives outside with you, not in a kitchen cupboard
  • Useful long after the turkey is eaten

Good to know

Needs its gauge checked before the day, not during

Safety value

9.8

Build

9.2

Ease of use

8.7

Value

9.5

#3 · Best thermometer for the bird

ThermoWorks Thermapen ONE Instant-Read Thermometer

9.6/10

One-second reads and the accuracy everyone else is measured against. If you buy one thing off this whole site, buy an accurate thermometer.

Type
Instant-read probe
Read time
About 1 second
Accuracy
Within about 0.5F
Use
Meat and oil spot checks

Why we picked it

  • One-second reads, so the lid is open for less time
  • Accurate enough to trust a single reading
  • Used constantly all year, not once

Good to know

Costs more than the rest of this list combined

Accuracy

9.8

Speed

9.8

Build

9.6

Value

8.6

#4 · Best oil thermometer

CDN Deep Fry Thermometer, 12 Inch Long Stem

9.3/10

A dial on a 12-inch stem that reads oil temperature continuously. The gauge built into a cheap kit is often the thing that is wrong.

Range
100F to 500F
Stem
12 in stainless
Dial
1.75 in, glass lens
Reads
Oil, not meat

Why we picked it

  • Twelve-inch stem clears a deep pot rim
  • Continuous reading while the oil comes up to 350F
  • Replaces the vague gauge on a budget kit

Good to know

Reads oil only — it will not tell you the bird is done

Accuracy

9.0

Build

8.9

Ease of use

9.3

Value

9.6

#5 · Best lifting gear

King Kooker Turkey Rack and Lifting Hook Kit

9.3/10

A rack and hook you can actually grip. Lifting a bird out on a bent wire is where most of the frightening fryer stories start.

Includes
Turkey rack and lifting hook
Finish
Chrome
Pairs with
King Kooker fryer packages
Use
Lowering and lifting the bird

Why we picked it

  • Lets you lower and raise the bird slowly and straight
  • Doubles as a drain hanger over the pot
  • Stainless, so it stores without rusting

Good to know

Check the fit against your pot before the day

Safety value

9.5

Build

9.2

Ease of use

9.0

Value

9.5

#6 · Best frying oil

ANF Brands Pure Peanut Oil, 4.5 Gallon Jug

9.3/10

Peanut oil is the default for a reason: a high smoke point and a flavour that does not fight the bird. One 4.5-gallon jug covers a 30-quart pot with margin.

Volume
4.5 gallon jug
Type
Pure peanut oil
Also
Kosher certified
Reuse
Strain and refrigerate, 2-3 fries

Why we picked it

  • Roughly 450F smoke point, well clear of 350F cooking
  • Neutral flavor that does not fight the brine
  • Three-gallon jugs match a 30-quart pot

Good to know

Costs real money at five gallons

Performance

9.6

Flavor

9.3

Value

8.4

Availability

9.0

Frequently asked questions

One rated for cooking-oil fires — Class K, or a standard ABC unit described as grease-rated. State Farm specifically warns never to use water or a garden hose on a fryer fire, because it is a grease fire and water spreads burning oil.

Our recommendation

If you only take one thing from this page: buy the GEEKHOM fryer gloves. If that is not the right fit for your setup, the First Alert extinguisher is the one to get instead.

Best fryer accessories

9.5/10

GEEKHOM 18 in Heat-Resistant Waterproof Cooking Gloves

Oven mitts stop at the wrist. Hot oil does not.

Runner-up — The one nobody sells you

9.5/10

First Alert Standard Kitchen Fire Extinguisher

A grease fire cannot be put out with water.

Brands: want your product tested? For Brands.

Sources

Related reading